The Future of Radio Ratings: Chicago’s Digital “Ratings” September 2011

Facebook matters. Twitter matters. Today these numbers are more real than ever.  Even more important are your website’s google analytics, your email database’s total subscribers, and ultimately your “open rate”.

These are the ratings of tomorrow. Actually, they are the ratings of TODAY, but everyone would rather focus on the VOODOO numbers published and paid for.

Like any ratings or statistics, these aren’t the end all be all. These are simply versions of VARIOUS available measuring sticks. These stats are an indicator of your stickiness…or lack of stickiness. These numbers are an indicator of the level of involvement your audience (or customers) have with your business/brand.

Enter the Chicago Radio Digital “Ratings” for September 2011 (We’ll post these monthly).  I am considering including Steve Dahl’s stats in the next period.  If you think there is someone else like Steve or a web entity that’s Chicago centric I should include, please suggest it in the comments below.

Chicago Radio’s Facebook Ratings September 2011:

Chicago Radio Facebook Ratings September 2011

My Predictions for Radio in 2009

Here are some of my predictions for the radio biz in 2009 and beyond:

1)  Sirius/XM will add another name to their merged moniker in an effort to stay alive.  (I’d really like to see Google gobble them up).  Someone will or they will merge yet again with another company.

2)  Ryan Seacrest will realize even more extreme national radio clearance the likes of which we have never seen….which will set the table for Howard Stern to return to terrestrial radio to larger affiliate clearance than he saw during his hey day….and a Rush Limbaugh pay-day to boot.  American Idol will have RECORD numbers this January….blowout record numbers.

3)  Nights will be the new overnights as stations and groups cut back.  Instead of experimenting with new ideas and formats at night, companies will continue to opt for jock free delivery post 7pm.

4)  Syndicated voicetracks (ala one of John Tesh’s delivery options as well as Seacrest’s) will sweep the nation allowing owners to get top notch “jocks” without Rush Limbaugh rates and ridiculous amounts of barter.  Look for the midday jock at name-your-hot-ac in Denver to be doling her tracks out to 10 other stations nationwide with custom tracks just for that station.  Stations who want to know more about this email me.

5)  MTV & VH1 styled repeats will hit PPM markets.  You know how Rock of Love is always on VH1….well look out because radio in PPM markets will become very similar.  Instead of burning non-music content once and never re-purposing it again, look for music stations to re-purpose and repackage their non-music content for repeat at various times throughout the day.  This will mean morning shows in the afternoon, countdowns repeated and much more.

6)  Shorter talk shows.  The days of the 5 hour morning show or 5 hour talk show are going to be numbered.  Just like repeating content will be more common place, so will more content and smaller doses of content.  Talk stations are going to embrace the 2 hour show, and probably run it twice.

7)  Weather will be the #1 local content/feature/benchmark for radio.  Weather is practically the #1 talking point of all time.  When in doubt, talk to someone about the weather and you have an instant conversation.  It will only increase as a “hot” topic for radio in 2009 based on the populations heightened awareness of climate issues, and radio’s lack of other “local” elements as time passes.

8)  Talent development and non-spot revenue will be lead by brokered programming.  Radio stations will broker more and more airtime that is off peak and even peak to pay the bills and get local programming at the same time.  This will be a tremendous opportunity for business savvy wannabe talent/programmers as well as business people who know how to use radio to get results for their business.

9)  The next revolution in radio will be the introduction of a Hamburger U type sales training academy for radio sales people.  Radio is being crippled by the drought of sales talent and this is an opportunity for either various broadcasting schools or a major broadcasting company.  My bet is on either TRN or Triton Media to lead the way in training and mentoring the next radio sales superstars.  They are the ones who can revive this business.  There has never been a talent drought on the programming side.  Great talents have come and gone with great radio stations because of an inability to sell.  Radio groups will invest in sales consultants and eschew programming consultants.

10)  Arbitron will become a measurement system for the exclusive purpose of bragging rights and programming adjustments.  The sales teams of the future will not be selling 40,000 AQH, but will instead be delivering 40 car buyers per month.  Reach will be replaced with results.  The new sales talent will design programs that sell results for their clients based on real numbers….not guess-timates.

11)  Direct Response advertising will be the model for 80% or more of the spots running nationally, and locally while 60% of radio revenue will be non-spot, non-sponsorship related.

12)  All the programming talent that fought off joining “sales” for all these years will reconsider their stance as they see opportunity in brokering time, selling radio campaigns that work and producing their way back on the air as quality production and stellar writing become even more important.

13)  More and more AM stations will simulcast on the FM.  FM Sports, and various forms of FM talk will thankfully put the 5th lame rock station playing Boulevard of Broken Dreams off the dial in your market, USA.

14)  Radio Disney will migrate to FM and claim their tween-ers and once they do, competition for the 6-12 year old demo will expand to include Nickelodeon and others….which will in turn spawn a revival in what was thought to be a lost demo for radio.

15)  Streaming and websites will both get better and worse.  All the bad websites will only get worse.  The streams of the same station you can get on the FM or AM dial will make less and less sense as time passes unless supplemented with additional options for customized personal listening.  Any radio company with a radio station website will be doomed.  The winners will have lifestyle websites for their audiences.

16)  Westwood One will get gobbled up by Triton Media (if the feds will allow that and it doesn’t seem as though they’re disciminating against much lately) or somehow, someway….Sirius XM will find a way to make a play for them which would set the table nicely for Howard’s triumphant return to terrestrial radio and Mel’s ability to leverage his Sirius XM content elsewhere.

17)  In Chicago, either WLS AM or WGN AM are going to have a better year…and the other one is going to choke.  Bonneville’s 3 stations will continue to dominate and grow.  CBS’s balance sheet will look better, but audience share and revenue share will suffer dramatically…and the tough question will be deciding which of their properties NOT to blow up as they’re all going to look pretty rough.  Emmis is in trouble.  There’s so much opportunity and I don’t expect them to discover how to capture it on 2009…..but Marv and Tisa…I’ve got some ideas…I know what you’re thinking…why would you listen to me?  My queston is why would you listen to the same consulting company you’ve been listening to for years, for yet another year?  I’d like to see someone get wise and program and sell a station to the suburbs….a chicago stick.  I mean forget about the city and the miracle mile….oak street beach….yada yada yada.  Design a station around the people who live, work, and spend their money in the suburbs…and you’ll make a mint.

That’s enough for now I think.  Happy New Year!  Please feel free to add your predictions below and we’ll see what shakes out in 2009.

Radio Rescues Chicago’s 4 Hour Nightmare Commute

December 16, 2008 is the day many folks will remember as “the day traffic stood still” for upwards of 4 hours.  Upwards of 4 hours. Now try as you might, you’d be hard pressed to gab on the phone to friends and loved ones for 4 hours.

You can’t watch TV in a car for 4 hours….safely.

You can’t read the newspaper for 4 hours in your car….safely.

But there’s always the good old RADIO.

So as radio faces the toughest times in radio HISTORY, you’d think radio would have seized this opportunity right!?  I mean we all knew this storm was coming hours ahead of time.

I am happy to report that radio sprung into action.

The Mix in Chicago (WTMX) had a team of producers cutting up best of audio from Eric & Kathy’s show.  They packaged it perfectly with voice overs from station voice John Pleisee and billed this special 4+ hours of Eric and Kathy in the afternoon as The Mix Presents Eric & Kathy’s Polar Express!  It was great!  Instead of listening to 14 songs an hour and traffic updates that helped not, we were entertained in our cars and 4 hours felt like 45 minutes!

The Loop in Chicago (WLUP) went so far as to bring Jonathon Brandmeier back for a live afternoon show!  I was flabbergasted when I heard Johnny B. taking phone calls and talking with listeners about the worst pot holes in Chicago, the BEST place to stop off for a beer, and the ultimate beef joints.  Johnny could have told Loop management to piss off and he’s the MORNING guy, but he gets it.  He knows radio and The Loop specifically are having a tough time and he’s their star.  All they had to do was ask and Johnny B. was on the scene proving why he’s been a Chicago institution for decades, and why he’ll continue to be worth every penny of his big radio salary down the road, if he’s utilized properly.

Jack FM (WJMK) in Chicago was the real shocker though.  I about flipped my car over when I heard Steve Dahl and Buzz Killman on in the afternoon!  The ink wasn’t even dry on their pink slips and here they were, doing what they do best….entertaining Chicago in afternoon drive.  It was an out-of-the box move by CBS Chicago management, but brilliant.  If AC stations can flip to Christmas music and see a boost surely the PPMs will reflect this risk….and it’s really not a risk since they were already paying Steve anyway.  What a great way to do some R&D!  Steve was smart for making it happen even though he had to secure studio time in Florida to make it work.  It’s times like these when you remember what you love about radio in Chicago.

Kiss FM (WKSC) in Chicago took an entirely different approach.  They had their morning star Drex piped in from his apartment via the web while co-host Mel T. was in studio.  It was another creative way of taking advantage of an opportunity to entertain to a captive audience during a unique time when the same old songs just wouldn’t do, and it worked brilliantly.  The best part was they had chances to txt your snails pace time to the station to win secret santa prizes and they even qualified 12 listeners for a trip to Mexico!  On my end of the speakers, a trip to someplace warm with NO SNOW sounded great!  They said they had over 10,000 people register via text in 15 minutes!  I bet their database exploded from this experiment.

Sadly, none of this actually happened.  The talk stations talked.  The music stations played music.  To make matters worse, the music stations did lots of traffic updates which really didn’t help.

Wake up radio.  If you’re just playing music when something big is happening in your audience’s life, you’re not connecting.  Someone will, and there’s going to be a line of sponsors waiting to reward the mavericks who make an effort.  There will also be plenty of room in the old media graveyard for those who try to keep on trucking with the same boring approach.



6 Responses to ““Nightmare Commute” – Chicago Tribune”

  1. mattdubiel on December 17th, 2008 8:32 am

    Oh by the way….

    Thursday and Friday of this week MIGHT be just as bad as the “Nightmare Commute” Tuesday…

    Radio programmers, GET READY NOW.

  2. JP on December 17th, 2008 8:46 am

    You had me fooled….I was reading it thinking “WOW!”

  3. BL on December 17th, 2008 11:51 am

    Totally sucked into your narrative! I think I caught on when I found myself thinking “how can all of these broadcasters have come up with creative programming and resources simultaneously?” We all know that doesn’t happen.

    And that’s very sad.

  4. Scott on December 17th, 2008 12:19 pm

    So, put morning shows on in the afternoon. That’s the solution? I may be wrong, but hasn’t this been done already…and failed?

    A station should be entertaining every afternoon. Not just in emergencies. If they’re not, then for Pete’s sake, don’t call attention to it by occasionally putting your morning talent on for the drive home.

    And what’s wrong with frequent traffic updates on a day like that? Seems to me that the top things on commuters’ minds that afternoon would be the weather and traffic.

    I agree whole-heartedly about thinking outside the box. But, I don’t think telling the audience that you’ve got second-string talent on in the afternoon, and you’re benching them to make room for the first-stringers today, sends the right message. Because tomorrow afternoon you’re going to tune in and think, “Gee. If the station doesn’t have any confidence in this guy, why should I?”

  5. Craig on December 22nd, 2008 2:22 pm


    Real listeners don’t think like that. At all.. only radio people. Bottom line, it’s either entertaining or it isn’t. There is no set formula.. well there actually is.. which is why radio is so average. If your station has the goods, use it. Maximize it… I do afternoons at KissMilwaukee.. I wouldn’t be offended if they brought in Wes, Rahny, and Alley to “takeover” during a blizzard. I would enjoy it.. possibly learn something from it..
    As a radio talent, you have to adapt constantly. Radio will never = comfortable. But that’s what makes it interesting